TECHNICAL DOCUMENTATION
SSP 090 CSS Increase customer satisfaction

This PDF is currently unavailable.
Read document text
Increase customer satisfaction with the CSS studyProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Self-study programmeŠKODA Service®90IntroductionLadies and gentlemen,you are holding in your hand the 90th part of the selfstudy programme "Increase customer satisfaction with the CSS". At first you might ask yourself the question: "What can I learn from this self-study programme?" Or: "What can I use it for?" The following is therefore an overview of the contents of this self-study programme. We shall deal with the subject of customer satisfaction and introduce you to a model for its systematic improvement. You will learn how customer satisfaction and customer loyalty with the CSS system are monitored and how to analyse weak points. In addition, you will learn how to derive concrete measures from this analysis for your service work and plan what is important for their implementation. This self-study programme explains the basic functioning of the CSS. It is shown here pragmatically, howa service operation integrates the CSS as a tool in the systematic improvement for increasing customer satisfaction. This is why you should already be familiar with the Škoda portal and its reporting method. This self-study programme is aimed at the service management, because it is their responsibility to organise improvement measures. However, there is no doubt: Best quality of service and customer satisfaction are the goals of all employees in the service. For this reason it is essential to involve all service employees in the planning and implementation of improvement measures for customer satisfaction. We hope you will enjoy reading this self-study programme as well as learning from it and we wish you abundant success for its implementation in your company.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�2GBContents1. Customer satisfaction and customer loyalty .......................................................................................................................4 2. Model for the systematic improvement of customer satisfaction ................................................................................9 3. Increase customer satisfaction and customer loyalty with the CSS ...........................................................................12 4. Improvement of customer satisfaction as a continuous process ................................................................................47 5. Test your knowledge................................................................................................................................................................49Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�The groups of persons mentioned in the self-study programme about organisation refer to both men and women. For reasons of readability and simplicity, the feminine form has not been used. The CSS instrument is explained as much as possible, regardless of certain forms of representation. Layout, structure and navigation of the CSS portal change over time, however the basic functioning remains the same. If screenshots from the CSS portal are shown in this self-study programme, they only serve to illustrate particular aspects of the CSS analysis, but do not explain the work with the portal.GB31. Customer satisfaction and customer loyaltyIn this chapter you will learn: – – – – what is customer satisfaction what is customer loyalty that customer satisfaction is a prerequisite for customer loyalty and how the two are linked what factors influence customer loyalty and guarantee long-term success of the company.1.1. 1.1.1.Definitions Customer satisfactionThe customer satisfaction reflects the quality of services from the perspective of the customer. Every customer of a car dealership has personal expectations, he perceives his environment differently and assesses individually what he perceives. Hence not only the objective performance is important for the development of customer satisfaction, but mainly the performance perceived subjectively by the customer. It is therefore important to know and use appropriate methods in order to make this subjective customer opinion measurable and comparable.Example: The repair order was indeed successfully processed, however, the customer was not offered a drink by the service advisor during the waiting period. Depending on how important it is to the customer to spend the waiting period as pleasantly as possible, he will be satisfied or dissatisfied in spite of objective order fulfillment.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�4GBThe term customer satisfaction is the relationship between customer expectations and the fulfillment of those expectations. The customer then compares his expectations with the quality of services perceived subjectively. If his expectation and the resulting performance match, this generally leads to customer satisfaction.Three important rules for the service can derive from this:1. If the customer expectation is fulfilled, the customer is satisfied. 2. If the customer's expectations are exceeded, the customer is delighted and more than satisfied. 3. If the customer's expectations are not met, the customer is disappointed and dissatisfied.1.1.2. Customer loyaltyCustomer loyalty is when repeated contacts and business relationships (inquiries, interviews, repair orders, purchases, etc.) between the customer and the car dealership come about. Establishing and maintaining a loyal customer will depend on a long-term and continuous cooperation. An important aspect that can influence customer loyalty positively is when the customer is satisfied repeatedly and when it is convenient for him to bring his vehicle back to your repair shop. For the economic success of a car dealership, customer loyalty is crucial among other factors.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB51.2.Relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyaltyHigh customer satisfaction is an important prerequisite for high customer loyalty. One can say: Customer satisfaction does not always and necessarily lead to customer loyalty, but a dissatisfied customer will never be faithful to the repair shop!The repair shop must therefore strive to make sure the customer is satisfied so that he will become a long-term loyal customer. This creates significant potential for the long-term economic success of the car dealership. These include cost-effective direct advertising, etc., easier acquisition of new customers through referrals, a good image, more orders, etc.1.3. Influence on customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in relation to long-term success of the companyVarious studies estimate that the cost to acquire new customers are up to five times as high as maintaining existing customer relationships. Often it is more useful and cost-effective to keep a customer and to meet his expectations or surpass them than to seek new customers. This assumes that the availability of new customers is limited and that the customers can of course also use competing offers. Even though the circle of potential customers should be relatively large, the satisfaction of existing customers is of enormous importance - dissatisfied customers act in a circle of friends and acquaintances as "negative multipliers".Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�6GBCustomer satisfaction and customer loyalty are therefore not an end but a means for the car dealership to achieve economic goals. The characteristic variable for achieving these goals is the quality of services from the customer's perspective.Customer satisfaction and customer loyalty have a direct and lasting impact on the following economic characteristic variables of the repair shop:1. Performance guarantee of the business relationship 2. Growth opportunities 3. Profi tability 4. Price tolerance of the customerPerformance guarantee of the business relationship The long-term duration of the relationship between the car dealership and the customer leads on both sides to a higher error tolerance. Business relationships will not stop immediately if any of the parties involved do not immediately comply with its obligations. Furthermore, it is difficult for competitors to acquire a loyal customer for themselves.Growth opportunities Altogether, regular customers can provide higher overall sales at the car dealership through repetitive purchases, repeated repair and service contracts or through cross-selling effects. The so-called cross-selling effect should not be neglected. If the customer is really satisfied, he will recommend the workshop to his friends, acquaintances and relatives - that can easily gain new customers without additional costs.Cross-selling Cross-selling means in marketing, the sale of complementary products or services. For example: Inspection and reserve oil or winter check and winter tyres.Company's profitability The higher sales through regular customers and the lower costs for acquiring new customers can lead to increased profitability for the workshop.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Price tolerance of the customer A high level of customer loyalty increases a sense of willingness to accept somewhat higher prices. Despite higher prices, the customer continues to buy products, maintain and repair his vehicle and does not switch to the competition.GB7QUALITYindividual customer expectationscomparisonquality perceived subjectivelynot fulfilledfulfilledexceededdissatisfied / disappointedgenerally satisfiedvery satisfied / more than satisfiedCUSTOMER SATISFACTIONCUSTOMER LOYALTYIMPACT ON LONG-TERM ECONOMIC RESULTSPerformance guarantee of the business relationshipGrowth opportunitiesCompany's profi tabilityPrice tolerance of the customerProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Fig. 1 Influence of service quality on customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and long-term success of the company8GB2.Model for the systematic improvement of customer satisfactionIn this chapter you will learn: – – – why it makes sense to plan and implement improvement measures systematically that regularly measuring customer satisfaction is a prerequisite for the development and testing of improvement measures how the improvement of customer satisfaction is shown on a circulation modelAs mentioned beforehand, a satisfied customer is an important prerequisite for the long-term success of the company. Each company should therefore seek to achieve high customer satisfaction and maintain it. To achieve visible and lasting good results, new improvements must always be introduced systematically. A goal-oriented manager must continuously determine and evaluate customer satisfaction and suggest appropriate measures on the basis of the results and take relevant action. The systematic approach increases the success of the measures introduced and also gives direction to the workshop manager and his team for their everyday decisions. It is about determining customer satisfaction, improving the quality of services and optimising the relationships with the customers.Service quality The service quality received by the customer results from the quality of work and care Quality of work + Quality of support = Quality of serviceProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB9The following circulation is based on the systematic improvement of customer satisfaction:1. 2. 3. 4. 5.Determine the current status Analyse the actual state Analyse the causes Derive and plan the measures Implement the measures6. (1.) Measure the achieved results / current status, etc.1. Determine the current status The measurement is used to determine professionally the actual state of customer satisfaction on the basis of a representative selection of customers. The measuring result is a qualified report, which can be used for further analysis.2. Analyse the actual state Following the measurement, the measuring result must be analysed and the actual state can be determined. The identification of weak points in the company is therefore of particular importance.3. Analyse the causes Then the deeper causes of the identified problems must be analysed and designated. If a remedy must really be found, one cannot only work with the signs.4. with Derive the of measures respect and to the plan correctness information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.� Only in this phase, concrete measures can be derived and planned - at this point a measurable goal and a set period must be fixed and a person responsible for the implementation must be designated.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability5. Implement the measures In the next step, the selected measures are implemented and the implementation is monitored.Then the effectiveness of the actions is measured again based on the actual state and the circuit diagram closes again through this. The company can use the benefits of the standardised CSS process in many points of this circulation model, which describes the process of systematically increasing customer satisfaction. This is explained in the following sections.10GBLOW CUSTOMER SATISFACTION1. Determine the current status5. Implement the measures CSS2. Analyse the actual state4. Derive and plan the measuresProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�3. Analyse the causesCSSHIGH CUSTOMER SATISFACTIONFig. 2 Model for the systematic improvement of customer satisfactionGB113.Increase customer satisfaction and customer loyalty with the CSS systemDetermine the current status3.1.In this chapter you will learn: – – – – – – about the structure of the CSS questionnaire about the criteria to select customers for this survey what is an optimal survey sample size for the CSS how the survey is conducted that there are different standards for evaluating the results that current and accurate information about the customer decides the quality of the report for the CSSTo improve customer satisfaction at company level, it must be measured how satisfied the customers are with the respective company. This measurement is performed using the CSS system (Customer Satisfaction Survey). The CSS is the study of measuring customer satisfaction at the level of the Škoda service companies.CSS for the sale and service The measuring of customer satisfaction is performed separately for sales and service. This self-study programme is based on the CSS for the CSS area.Basic information about CSS Start Areas Makes Development Worldwide use The customer satisfaction (CSS) has been monitored since 2003. It was gradually introduced in different markets and its design is constantly evolving. Separate implementation for sales and after sales of the relevant markets Separate implementation for the makes Škoda, Volkswagen, Audi, Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles, Seat. The CSS was developed by the companies GfK and TNS, which deal with the market research. Currently in all major markets, standardised telephone call for Škoda After Sales (modifications only after approval of the manufacturer for technical and cultural reasons).Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�12GB3.1.1. How is the questionnaire structured?In chapter 1 was explained how customer satisfaction and customer loyalty are related. One can say: Customer satisfaction does not always and necessarily lead to customer loyalty, but a dissatisfied customer will never be faithful to the repair shop!Four questions in the questionnaire of the CSS serve as common performance assessment and determination of customer loyalty: Question 1 Overall satisfaction with the service Question 2 Recommendation Question 3 Next visit Question 4 Advantage when using the services If you think about your experience during your last workshop visit, how satisfied have you been with the service as a whole? Would you recommend this service to your friends and colleagues? Would you let your next repair or maintenance be carried out again in this workshop? Based on your requirements which you place on the service, how are these requirements fulfilled in comparison with other workshops?Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�The answers to these four questions have the same importance in the customer retention index - customer loyalty (see description of the key figures in chapter 3.2).GB13The CSS questionnaire contains questions on important individual aspects, which are based primarily on the "service core process" and which can be assessed subjectively by the customer during the process and/or from the result.1 Appointments– all superior aspects (see page 15 bottom right) Consideration of appointment requests2 Appointment preparation– all superior aspects (see page 15 bottom right)21The service3 Order acceptance/order creation– all superior aspects (see page 15 bottom right) (offer of a replacement vehicle) explanation of the workshop work prior to the implementation description of the work on the vehicle preliminary information about the price price in compliance with the already accomplished advance information delays in the company344 Repair/service provision– -all superior aspects (see page 15 bottom right) correct execution of the work required time of work execution compliance with the completion date no repeated repairProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Fig. 3 Questions of the CSS questionnaire14GBThese aspects are assigned in Figure 3 to the individual steps in the service core process. In addition, some statistical questions including, for example, age and gender, as well as additional questions, such as the main reason for the ultimate cause of the workshop visit are contained in this questionnaire.7 Finishing process– all superior aspects (see bottom right)6 Vehicle return/billing-7Core process6-all superior aspects (see below) Consideration of appointment requests explanation of work/billing price in compliance with the already accomplished advance information delays in the companyProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�5 Quality control/vehicle return preparationall superior aspects (see right)–5Superior aspects for all steps in the service core process:price-performance ratio friendliness of service employees expertise of service employees response to concerns and wishes of the customersGB153.1.2. How are the customers for the CSS survey selected?The CSS examination is performed for each Škoda repair shop on the basis of a representative selection of customers (sample). The actual respondents are randomly selected from the so-called basic population. The basic population is the sum of the customers that are acceptable for participation in the CSS examination.Basic population Not all workshop customers are suitable to participate in the CSS survey. The customer must meet the following conditions in order to be included in the basic population and be part of the sample:--It is a private customer or a self-employed customer with a small company. Customers from large companies and fleet customers (the target person is often difficult to reach) are acceptable only if they provide a contact partner. The last workshop visit of the customer is in the relevant event month for which data collection is still running (for the reporting periods, see chapter 3.1.4.).All customers who meet these conditions, can theoretically be the respondents in the CSS examination. In general, however, not all these customers are interviewed, but a certain number of customers is selected. This group of selected customers is called sampling.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�16GBSampleIn order to draw conclusions from the results of the investigation regarding the satisfaction of all customers of the basic population, the sampling must meet certain criteria:-It must be a sample selection, i.e. which does not favour any person during the selection. The respondents must be randomly selected. A sufficiently large number of customers must be questioned in order to achieve a reliable result. The optimal sample size must be determined for this.All workshop customersBasic populationSampleFig. 4 unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.� Of all the customers of the company for samplingProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permittedGB17Optimum size of the sampleThe most accurate result would be obtained if one would ask all the customers. Such an overall survey would be very costly. When performing the test again on a very small number of customers, it can be that the testimony in several cases does not reflect the opinion of the entire basic population. As a compromise between the highest possible quality and the lowest possible cost, a reasonably accurate, but at the same time financially reasonable sample size must be defined.Statistical methods assist us in this decision making. Such a calculation was performed beforehand for the CSS with the result that a sample of 120 questionnaires (number of successful interviews conducted) in a calendar year (12 individual waves, each of which represents one month) is optimal for each Škoda service operation.Consequently, so that the sample for the whole year is divided equally, 10 questionnaires net per month are allocated to each workshop. The increase in annual sampling would result in no significant gain in accuracy. For service companies with higher order numbers (more than 9000/year) the amount of samples is increased proportionally by 20 questionnaires per month.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�18GB3.1.3. How is the survey conducted?The CSS survey is conducted as a telephone conversation which lasts several minutes. The interview time can vary depending on the customer and the market (if necessary questions significant for individual markets are asked, which exceed the international CSS standard). The interviewer uses a computer program that guides him through the questionnaire and allows immediate entry of the answers.For the subsequent overall evaluation, the results of individual interviews must be comparable. Therefore, the questionnaire is standardised for all interviews - the choice of answers and the order of the questions are identical.The market research is carried out as follows: The importer commissions a market research company to conduct the telephone calls. The upstream address management is usually performed by a provider for address services, the downstream reporting by a reporting agency (such as TNS, GfK and others).The questions in the CSS questionnaire can be divided essentially into two different types of questions:-questions on satisfaction questions on fulfillment (yes/no)Besides, there are questions that have different qualitative response alternatives (e.g., question 5 "The main reason of the last workshop visit").Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB19Questions on satisfactionWith these questions, the degree of satisfaction with a particular aspect of performance is established.The respondent is given five response categories, from which he must select the most applicable one. The alternatives are:-extremely satisfied very satisfied satisfied less satisfied dissatisfiedExample How satisfied are you with the explanation of the necessary workshop work prior to its implementation?Following the definition given in Chapter 1, customer satisfaction results from a subjective comparison of the service provided with the existing expectation. The result can vary within a range between non-fulfillment via fulfillment up to over-fulfillment.This spectrum has been involved in the development of response options. Furthermore, the scale provides a slightly more effective differentiation between high performances and "only" good performances.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�20GBThe more satisfied the customer is with the specific aspect, the better the "grade" (from 1 to 5) that the workshop receives when calculating the average. The average value is calculated from all the valid responses of the customers during the accounting period. In addition to the average score as part of the results, the percentage distribution of responses in each category of responses is given.Response categoriesImportance (points per category) Škoda VW group +12 +8 +4 0 -4Number of responsesPoints for the overall resultŠkoda 17 36 28 5 4 90 213 213/90 = 2,37 1 x 17 = 17 2 x 36 = 72 3 x 28 = 84 4 x 5 = 20 5 x 4 = 20VW group 12 x 17 = 204 8 x 36 = 288 4 x 28 = 112 0x5=0 -4 x 4 = -16Extremely satisfied Very satisfied Satisfied Less satisfied Dissatisfied Total answers Total points Average mark/average points1 2 3 4 5588 588/90 = 6,53 *Example of the calculation: Calculating the average value for a question on satisfaction (number of respondents = 90) In the case of evaluation according to the group scale, the result is the number of points (-4 to 12). In the case of the calculation according to the Škoda scale, the result is a "school grade" (1-5). The evaluation between the two scales can be converted using the following formula: Group scale = 4 x (4 - Škoda note)Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Example, group result = 4 x (4 - 2.37) = 6.52** The difference is a result of rounding up.GB21Questions on fulfillment (yes/no)Questions on fulfillment serve to determine whether a particular aspect has been fulfilled or not. Here, the respondent generally answers "yes" or "no". In addition to the average score as part of the results, the percentage distribution of responses in each category of responses is given.Example Has the promised completion date of the vehicle repair been kept? (Question 7E)Note In this case, there is a third possible answer: "Has not been agreed." These possibilities are not offered to the respondent, but they can be coded if necessary and later be included in the calculation. The same applies to the next standard category of answers which is possible for all questions and also not offered to the customer: "Unspecified".Response categoriesImportance (points per category) Škoda VW group +12Number of responsesPoints for the overall resultŠkoda 63 63 x 1 = 63VW group 12 x 63 = 756Yes/Has not been agreed No Total answers Total points Average points1 5Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability -4 27 27 x 5 = 135 -4 x 27 = -108 with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�90 90 198/90 = 2,2 648 648/90 = 7,2Example of the calculation: Calculating the average value for a question on fulfillment (number of respondents = 90) Note Conversion to the scoring according to the group scale, see page 21.22GB3.1.4. Which standard applies to the measured levels of satisfaction?When are the customers satisfied and when are they enthusiastic? There is no absolute standard for customer satisfaction. The point value reached for a specific question at a specific time (e.g., 1.2 or 1.4) allows no assessment of the results. In order to assess whether the satisfaction levels of the workshop are high or low, the calculated values of the actual workshop must be compared with other data. This comparison is performed in the CSS, in two ways.-Comparison with benchmarks Comparison over timeComparison with benchmarks Here, the company-specific values are compared for example with the average values of all companies in a country, region, or the limit value of the top 20% companies. The comparison shows where the workshop is placed as part of the respective reference group, where it achieves relatively good results, and where it is rather average and in which fields the other workshops achieve higher customer satisfaction.Comparison over time In this approach, the current company values are compared with the values of the same company during a previous period. The comparison shows how the values of customer satisfaction of the relevant workshop have evolved over time, whether they are better or worse.For both comparison variants, the CSS provides appropriate evaluations.Benchmark The reference value is designated as benchmark for the comparison analysis of the results. Considered as standard benchmarks in the CSS are:-National average: Weighted average of all companies in the country (Note: in order to take the higher number of customers in larger workshops into account when calculating the national average, the is average values of Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, not permitted authorised ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept sold". any liability the workshops are weightedunless according toby their size, usually by the characteristic value "hourswith respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�-Top 20 %: Average value of 20 % of the country's best companies.GB233.1.5. Reporting periods and sliding average valuesThe CSS survey is conducted continuously throughout the entire year. The monthly reports lead to results based on the monthly averages. In addition, the results are also calculated based on various sliding average values. Furthermore, the results are shown in the framework of the completed calendar quarter and accumulation of the given year. In order to calculate a sliding mean value, all interviews of the current month and a certain number of the previous months are summarised for the evaluation. 3 classic result presentations are used:-3 month overview 6 month overview 12 month overview3 month overview The results shown are a summary of the current month and the previous two months.01/1102/11 03/11 04/11 05/11 Report April 2011. Report May 201106/1107/1108/1109/1110/1111/1112/11Report June 20116 month overview The results shown are a summary of the current month and the previous five months.01/1102/1103/1104/11 05/11 06/11 Report July 2011 August 201107/1108/1109/1110/1111/1112/11September 2011Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.� 24GB12 month overview The results shown are a summary of the current month and the previous eleven months.01/1102/1103/1104/111st quarter05/11 06/11 07/11 08/11 09/11 Report December 2011 2nd quarter 3rd quarter Accumulation10/1111/1112/114th quarterAdvantages of sliding averages - When considering monthly values, the results of the CSS survey for the given workshop fluctuate strongly from month to month. This can be caused by a small number of interviews, without the results being influenced by the actual change in quality. A very small number of interviews already lead to significant changes in the company's average value through individual customer judgments (e.g. a dissatisfied customer). - By combining interviews of at least 3 months, the results are stabilised (target 30 cases). Higher reliability of results is achieved with a 6 month overview (target 60 cases) and very high reliability of results for a 12 month overview (target 120 cases). - Sliding averages slow down completely or partially through seasonal effects (as a result of action months, holidays, Christmas).We therefore recommend to use the strategic analysis of the actual state, the 6 month or 12 month overview. Ultimately, sliding averages promote a high reliability of results and thus allow reasonable and relevant action planning. Hasty steps that could be made on the basis of individual extreme fluctuations can thus be avoided.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB253.1.6. The quality of customer data influences the measuring qualityMeasuring customer satisfaction is provided by the CSS, without the company carrying out its own survey. In order to systematically track customer satisfaction levels and improve them, the service operation is dependent on a high-quality measurement. Therefore each company has the task to enter the data of its customers in the systems and pass it on so that during the course of sampling and interviewing, a high quality of the measurement can be guaranteed. The service manager must ensure this.The customer data for the CSS examination is generated and processed in most markets in the computer system which is used by the workshop (Dealer Management System). A high quality of results is only achieved when all of the required customer data for the CSS examination from all the orders is at least handed over once a week completely and without error to the editing interface. This applies particularly to small businesses, which otherwise do not reach the required sample size.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�26GB3.2.Analysing the actual stateIn this chapter you will learn: - about the key figures which help to analayse the actual stateFirst of all, the current situation of the workshop must be analised in order to assess customer satisfaction systematically and improve it. Thereby, the strengths and weaknesses of the company must be determined. Information about the current situation can be obtained from the measured data. However, the company must not do this effort on its own. The CSS system provides - in addition to detailed results - in particular a number of characteristic values and summaries of the individual questions.These key figures and overviews are:-Customer loyalty index (CRI) Performance criteria Analysis of strengths and weaknessesIndividual indicators and overviews are presented in the following subchapters and the procedure for analysing the current situation is explained.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB273.2.1. Customer loyalty indexHow strong the loyalty of a customer is to the service operation is established in the CSS by means of the customer loyalty questions (see chapter 3.1).Customers are bound more closely to the company:-the higher their overall satisfaction with the last workshop visit the more likely they are to recommend this workshop to friends and colleagues, the more likely they have their next repair or maintenance carried out again in the workshop (this question is derived from the additional risk potential, see illustration on next page), the better their requirements are fulfilled in comparison with other workshops.The mean value of these four aspects is the customer loyalty index.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available. Fig. 5 The customer loyalty index shown in the CSS portal (Report 10/2011); sample workshop)28GBThe customer loyalty index is very important because it captures the overall picture that the customer perceived during his last visit to the workshop and reflects the customer's perceptions. The values of the customer loyalty index and the questions related to this can therefore not be directly influenced, because it is an overall picture of the customer in relation to the workshop which does not consider specific services. If, however, the individual central services or characteristics significantly improve or deteriorate, so does the customer loyalty index develop in the same direction.The greater the influence of a specific performance (for example, the explanation of the service work prior to their implementation) or the entire subject area (e.g. the quality of the repair) on the customer loyalty index, the more this index changes with the change in the result of the relevant performance or the specific subject area. Therefore a statistical context exists, which is measurable.The concrete measures will therefore always be geared towards the improvement of individual topics and important issues.Next visit to the workshop/potential riskProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available. Fig. 6 Potential risk in the CSS portal (Report 01/2011; sample workshop)GB29Moments of Truth* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available.Fig. 7 Analysis of the strengths and weaknesses shown in the CSS portal (Report 01/2011; sample workshop). * At the time of preparation of this language version the print screen was only available in Czech.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�30GB3.2.2. Moments of TruthThe moments of truth are those aspects of the questionnaire, which overall have the greatest relationship with the customer loyalty index and/or a particularly high strategic importance for the Škoda brand.The "Moments of Truth" consist of the following individual aspects:-explanation of the workshop work prior to the implementation correct execution of the service work no repeated repair friendliness of service employees response to concerns and wishes of the customers explanation of work/billing price-performance ratioProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available. Fig. 8 Moments of Truth in the CSS portal (Report 01/2011; sample workshop)GB313.2.3. Analysis of strengths and weaknessesSelected aspects are looked at more closely in the analysis of strengths and weaknesses. Questions from the CSS questionnaire are addressed and grouped into logical themes, which also have a large impact on the customer loyalty index. The analysis of strengths and weaknesses is a very good starting point for analysing the current situation. The following table shows the analysis of strengths and weaknesses from the CSS system on the opposite screenshot:Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available. Fig. 9 Analysis of the strengths and weaknesses shown in the CSS portal (Report 01/2011; sample workshop).32GB3.2.4. Quality characteristicsThe quality characteristics always combine one or more statistically and contentwise related questions for the topics.The quality indicators can be considered topic display elements of customer loyalty. They are suitable for deeper analysis of the actual state. For each indicator the value calculated from the mean value of the individual questions, which are part of this subject area, is displayed. For the first stage of the analysis, the deviation of various indicators of service quality from the benchmark is monitored.When creating areas, standard benchmarks "national average" and "TOP 20%" can be selected (see fig. 10). A positive deviation shows strength of the workshop, a negative one weakness of the workshop. For quality indicators with the highest negative deviation, the largest elimination measures exist.In a second stage, the critical quality indicators are analysed in detail while considering the results of the relevant individual questions. In addition, the temporal development of the individual results of the questions is considered.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available. Fig. 10 Quality indicator: Customer treatment with benchmark Top 20% and 12 month overview in the CSS portal.GB333.2.5. Procedure for the analysisAt the beginning of the analysis is the question "Where do we stand compared to other workshops?" The reference value is always a benchmark. This general question should be further specified:1. What do we do better or at least as well as other workshops? Here are our strengths! We should try to keep them long term and use them when communicating with the customer. 2. What do other workshops do better? Here we still have potential for improvement. We must work long term and permanently to improve these issues. 3. What do other workshops do much better? Here are our weaknesses which require immediate action. Other workshops have shown us that much better results are possible. Such issues need systematic remedial actionDuring the continuous improvement process, the workshop manager with his team monitors whether the measures adopted indicate the desired effect. "Do our policies work in practice?" Meanwhile, are the effects resulting from the CSS questions, which were regarded as critical by the customer, positive? For checking, the development of the CSS results is monitored over time (see also chapter 3.5., section; The "success of the measures introduced"). The "competition" must always be observed during these considerations. We are interested to what extent our workshop can be improved in comparison with the benchmark: "Are we getting better in relation to other workshops?"All the main indicators and detailed questions are shown graphically in the CSS portal. The graphic illustration basically allows both, the comparison of own results to a benchmark, such as the national average in the TOP 20% and the examination of the values over time.When analysing the current situation, the analysis of strengths and weaknesses provides specific information about where immediate corrective action can be taken. For a detailed and deeper analysis of specific topics, the quality characteristics, or the individual questions, which arise from these characteristics are used.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�In the analysis it is important to focus on the weaknesses and take targeted, very specific measures for their elimination. Usually it is more efficient to focus more on some selected areas rather than trying to solve all problems at once. In this case the motto "less is more" applies, especially when there are many areas in the workshop that require costly remedial measures.34GB3.3.Analyse the causesIn this chapter you will learn: - that prior to meaningful improvement measures, a careful analysis of the causes is necessary - what a fishbone diagram is - how this diagram helps when analysing the causes - who was Kaoru IshikawaA central position in the overall model for the systematic improvement of customer satisfaction is the stage called "analysis of the causes". This important stage is often underestimated in the daily operation of the workshop or mixed with the analysis of the weaknesses or the development of measures. Only when separating the recognition of the weaknesses from the following cause analysis, practical and effective measures can be taken in the next stage. Thus, the risk of ineffective measures that require great effort and do not bring the desired effect can be minimised.Note At this point of the improvement process, it's all about the analysis of the causes, but not yet about working on the solutions.As already described in the preceding section, points can be recognised that require a remedy based on the analysis of weaknesses and strengths. The causes of the weaknesses can, however, not be directly recognised from the CSS examination. Their identification and designation follow in the next stage. At least now the team of the workshop should also be included in the remedial procedure. Thus, knowledge of the structures and processes are activated that are behind the actual opinions of the customers. When the employees are involved at this time, they can identify more easily with the later changes that may follow. Thus it can be achieved that the employees of the workshop take the quality of services rendered to heart and the future implementation of the measures will not encounter any strong opposition.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB35How can the causes be analysed efficiently? For the analysis of the causes, it is recommended to use the fishbone diagram. The fishbone diagram (Ishikawa diagram) is a simple technique for the analysis of problems and their causes.What is the fishbone diagram? In a fishbone diagram all possible causes of a problem are graphically presented in the form of main and side branches.What is the fishbone diagram? The various causes of a problem will be illustrated with the help of this diagram, which makes a structured approach to problem analysis possible. The fishbone diagram is a particularly good tool for teamwork.How does one proceed? 1. The problem must be clearly defined and confirmed by the team. 2. The category of the causes must be defined and entered on the ends of the main branches. 3. The main causes must be determined and entered on the main branches of the diagram. 4. The secondary causes must be determined and entered on the side branches of the diagram. 5. The developed diagram must be discussed and evaluated.Fishbone diagram (Ishikawa diagram) The diagram was named after its shape - as one can see in our example - it looks like a fishbone. It owes its second name, Ishikawa diagram, to its inventor. Ishikawa Kaoru was a Japanese chemist who developed a whole range of quality instruments, including this diagram which he invented in 1943.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�36GBCause2 Category Effect3Main cause1Problem4Secondary causeFig. 11 Design of the fishbone diagramGBProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�37To better illustrate the approach to the problem "Explaining the importance of the workshop prior to performing work" a fishbone diagram is created (Question 7/D2).To 1st and 2nd stage The workshop manager defines both the problem and the individual categories. He enters the problem (1) "Explanation of the importance of the workshop prior to performing work" (Question 7/D2) - in the dedicated box (fish head). Appropriate categories are entered on the ends of the main branches (2), for example, "personnel", "processes / procedures", "equipment", etc.The service manager should explain the problem and the category of causes to his team in advance, in order to ensure their consent.To 3rd and 4th stage At this moment, the workshop manager and his team play a part. All participants bring their own ideas. It is important that no idea is disregarded - the spectrum must vary as widely as possible. Criticism or judgments about the feasibility, order, etc. are not wanted at this time.The main causes which are defined in our example ("client has little time," too little time per order ", etc.) are each assigned to a category and entered in the corresponding main branch.In the same way, one proceeds with the secondary causes (4), such as "all the customers come in the morning at the same time", "time to explain the vehicle is not scheduled when making an appointment."Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�38GBTo 5th stage The diagram is now complete. In the final stage, the team evaluates the various causes. The aim of the evaluation is to select the most likely and most important causes. This selection forms the basis for the next work step "derive and plan the measures" (see section 3.4.)The order presented here is recommended, but not in every case (with the exception of point 1) mandatory for all cases. The development of a fishbone diagram is a creative process. Any changes, rearrangements and a different order are not wanted when creating the diagram.2Equipment2Processes, proceduresnot sufficient margin for meeting the customerthe customer has little time33the time for the explanation is not planned in when scheduling the appointment too little time for the order4 3 4 1The customers are not satisfied with the explanation of the service work prior to its implementation (Question 7D2)3all customers come in the morning at the same time3The service advisor does not explain all service work of an order3too few service advisors during the rush hour3 2Other2PersonnelProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Fig. 12 Concrete example of a fishbone diagramGB393.4.Derive and plan the measuresIn this chapter you will learn: - what measures can be derived and planned systematically - which questions the team supports during this procedureWe have completed the analysis of causes. We can divide the next phase into two independent stages:1. Propose measures 2. Plan measuresThe specifications stipulated in these two stages must be meaningful, concrete, achievable and verifiable. Answering the following questions is helpful in the derivation and planning of the improvement measures:Causes identifiedProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�1st cause 2nd cause 3rd cause 4th cause Cause ...1. Propose measures2. Plan measuresWhich measures should be taken? Which measures should/can be taken?What exactly should be done? How should it be done?Who should do it and until when?Fig. 13 Derive and plan the measures40GB3.4.1. Propose measuresWhich measures should be taken? Similar to the analysis of the causes in chapter 3.3. as many ideas as possible must first of all be gathered. All possible measures, related to a specific cause, are discussed. It is a creative process where it is important to collect as many ideas as possible without already examining their measures.Which measures should/can be taken? The proposals from the pool of measures are now being worked out while assessing their feasibility. Those measures are selected, which promise the greatest success.3.4.2. Plan measuresWhat exactly should be done? The more precisely is defined and described what needs to be done, the fewer misunderstandings and ambiguities arise. The answer to this question should therefore help to plan specific actions.How should it be done? The more concrete is defined how the measure should be implemented, the clearer and easier is the implementation for the employees. These include among others the provision of funds and resources. Depending on the type of measure, it may be important to determine the number, frequency or timing of activities to be undertaken. Just because of these technical details, the employees should be involved in the planning process. Only then can their creativity, knowledge and experience be used and the positive acceptance of the changes ensured in time. The action plan will be implemented individually for individual workshops in the application "Feedback" and in the application "action plan". The service partner must devote the possibility of direct response to quite specific comments of his customers and to the areas where he does not achieve satisfactory results.Who should do it and until when? For the change process it is important that the decisions are controlled. Therefore, it should be determined who is responsible for what measure and by when it should be implemented. When defining repetitive and/or long-term activities, it must be stipulated on which dates the person in charge should be informed. Only in this way it can be ensured that the implementation of planned measures is not forgotten in the future. The proposed measures are always based on specific causes. You should consider all the peculiarities of the workshop and its surroundings.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�GB41Catalog of CSS measures* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�Fig. 14 Measures proposed in the application "Feedback" CSS measures. Critical area: Explanation of the work in the workshop prior to conducting work on the basis of customer feedback (Question 7 H), Report 01/2011; sample workshop42GBProtected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, in part or in whole, is not permitted unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. S.�* At the time of preparing this issue only Czech and English language versions were available.Fig. 15 Measures proposed in the application "action plan" CSS. Critical area: Understanding the problems and sufficient time for their solution (Question 7D.1), Report 01/2011; sample workshopGB433.5.Implement the measuresIn this chapter you will learn: - that the service manager can assist the implementation of the measures using competent leadership - which specific management responsibilities the service manager has at this stage - that it is important to consistently and continuously implement the planned measures for change - which time system is useful when tracking the effects of the measures in the CSS system.When all measures are fully planned, it is now a matter of implementing the project. All employees involved will be asked to pitch in and work on their specific tasks. The elaborated and documented action plan serves as a guide.Especially in the phase of implementation, the service performance can significantly support the success of the measures through competent employee management. It is the goal to turn all participating employees into active employees.Measures to improve customer satisfaction (e.g. extend the acceptance date or inform customers about faults that still exist) are often designed to optimise the organizational processes within the company and to improve communication with customers (e.g. welcome each customer with a handshake and name). This requires from all parties involved to change their habitual ways of working. The first steps are often made with great effort and sometimes met with opposition. It is important for the success that all service employees are constantly focused and working to implement the agreed changes.Protected by copyright. Copying for private or commercial purposes, part or in whole, is not permitted It is important that the service management provides guidance during the in procedure and sets a clear starting unless authorised by ŠKODA AUTO A. S. ŠKODA AUTO A. S. does not guarantee or accept any liability signal right from the beginning. This might take place in the form of team meetings where the manager with respect to the correctness of information in this document. Copyright by ŠKODA AUTO A. service S.� presents once more the objectives and the coordinated measures. Open questions can still be addressed at the meeting before everybody begins with the implementation.If the workshop introduces entirely new solutions, it usually takes some time until the new procedures are implemented. It is normal that not all works perfectly from the start. New procedures must be learned. When several employees are involved in carrying out measures, regular meetings assist these learning experiences.At the beginning of the support phase, the service manager has the task to provide intensive starting help for the process of change. He should motivate his employees to implement together what has been planned beforehand. It is important to take any concerns or opposition of employees seriously and assist them in finding solutions. People oppose in order to protect whatever already exists, and this opposition usually arises because of fears and insecurities, or if people assume that these changes will overtax them professionally or time-wise. Therefore, it is important not to take this lightly. The workshop manager must respond and carefully break them down by providing information and understanding. Only employees who accept the changes and are willing to change, can participate actively in the implementation of the measures.It is a further task of the service management to follow the progress of implementati